What methods may be used to exercise an option?
The most common methods involve the use of the following:
- a cashless same-day sale
- a sell-to-cover exercise
- stock you already own (i.e. a stock swap)
- a promissory note
- net options exercise
The table below outlines the way in which each exercise method works.
|Method||Cash paid to exercise||Cash received at exercise||Shares used to exercise||Shares received at exercise|
|Net options exercise||No||No||Sort of||Yes|
Check your company's stock plan for the allowed methods and procedures. Once you do give notice to exercise with payment as required under your stock plan, it is unlikely that you can then change your decision to exercise or the exercise method, at least for tax purposes. This is illustrated by the case of Walter v. Commissioner, decided by the US Tax Court (TC Memo 2007-2, January 3, 2007). The employee attempted to change his original exercise instructions from a same-day sale to a cash exercise/hold. The Tax Court did not let him, holding that he had beneficial ownership of the stock when he initially exercised the options following the conditions under his stock plan.
Alert: Companies very strictly follow their exercise rules and deadlines. See, for example, Deal v. Consumer Programs, Inc., a case involving expired stock options that was decided in 2006 by the US 8th Circuit Court of Appeal. The court ruled that the mere submission of a written notice to exercise stock options may be insufficient when the grant agreement states that the notice must be "accompanied by full payment of the purchase price of the shares."
For financial-planning ideas related to the methods and timing of option exercises, see the FAQs in the section Financial Planning: Strategies.